⏳ Read Time: 3.5 min, 863 words

New here? Read about the BETTER Team and Mission here.

Our first book, Lead Yourself First, is our field manual for coaches to build their Leadership. We’ve heard from many coaches who have read it, love it, and are taking their staff through it.

Haven’t gotten your copy yet?

Already read it? We’d deeply appreciate it if you leave us a review on Amazon.

Last week, we introduced the Talent–Culture Matrix.

The point isn’t classification.

The point is decision-making. Because in the portal era, you don’t get months to think clearly. You get hours. So this week, we want to look at the five most important insights we find in thinking like this.

Here are the five biggest takeaways we see across every sport, every level, every roster conversation.

The biggest mistake coaches make is thinking talent is additive. Players, rosters, and relationships are never just pluses or minuses.

It’s interactive.

Every player you add changes:

Which means that players doesn’t just raise your floor or your ceiling.

They reshape your entire system.

Your team is a living ecosystem. And what type of makeup you have is up to you more than you think. Sometimes for the better. Sometimes not.

We tend to treat culture like it’s a bonus. Something that’s helpful but secondary.

But, which one of the two (talent or culture) is easier to guarantee when evaluating players, fit, and impact? I think most coaches would say talent.

The data (and your own experience) says otherwise

But it’s actually very difficult to see how a player’s talent will impact the dynamics we discussed above.

Culture is actually easier.

Any culture kid doesn’t just add. They multiply.

They:

They are not neutral pieces.

They are multipliers.

Most coaches don’t, because they don’t know how to do it. But it’s really simple.

List out your values. Have your staff score each kid you’re recruiting, targeting, or even your returners on a 1-5 scale for each value. Average them and BOOM. You have a score out of 5 for how well your staff thinks that kid will fit your culture.

Is it perfect? No. There are more robust ways you could do this, and in a compressed timeline, it’s hard to get enough info on a player that you can feel confident in all your scores.

But, just in doing this exercise, your staff will also get better over time at identifying culture kids and identifying it in the recruiting process.

…which leads us to our next point.

What’s interesting is how rarely coaches are surprised. When we debrief seasons or portal decisions, the language is consistent:

The matrix doesn’t give you new information. It forces you to face the information you already have. It requires you to score what you intuitively know.

It’s not bad luck that a player didn’t work out. It came from ignored signals.

We say it all the time. You don’t want to keep any player from leaving.

It’s natural. It’s going to happen. It’s impossible to retain every player on any roster.

But what you want is to keep the right players. With whatever resources you have available, your entire roster strategy should be targeted at identifying, acquiring, and retaining the top-right quadrant.

Everyone wants “game changers.” Few programs consistently get them.

Why?

Because they’re not just recruiting talent.

And they do it earlier than everyone else.

Before the market fully values them.

That’s the edge.

Teams aren’t just a collection of players.

You’re building a living system.

And every addition either strengthens the system or introduces friction. There is no neutral.

Team building isn’t just about talent. It never has been and never will be.

It’s about the balance between talent and fit. Most coaches have very robust systems to identify talent.

But, where the value lies now is in identifying and valuing fit.

Do you know your culture clearly enough to do that? If not, start there.
If your culture is clear, what can you do to evaluate every current player and potential player against your culture?

Start today.

Get BETTER’s Culture Playbook. A system designed to install a thriving, healthy, high-performance culture. Join over 1,000 coaches who use our Culture Playbook from youth club teams to national championship NCAA programs and everything in between.