⏳ Read Time: 3 min

New here? Read about the BETTER Team and Mission here.

📌 What’s inside:

• 🧭 Why this wasn’t just an “unexpected” season

• 🧠 What most people missed while focusing on the outcome

• 🛠 Leadership lessons that travel to any program

Our Book is Out!

And not only is it out, but last week, our book hit #1 on Top New Releases in the Sports Category! Really cool to see coaches getting and using our manual, built by and for coaches, to lead themselves first!

Haven’t gotten your copy yet?

👸 Not All Cinderella Stories Feel the Same

Every season has its surprises. Nearly every season in every sport has its feel-good stories. It has teams that outperform expectations. Runs no one predicted.

But some seasons feel different.

Indiana football’s undefeated championship run didn’t just shock people. It unsettled them. Not because of what happened, but because it challenged many assumptions about how success is supposed to work in modern college athletics.

This wasn’t a roster full of stars. It wasn’t a program chasing trends. It wasn’t built on flash, hacks, or shortcuts.

What made it stand out wasn’t the result.
It was the clarity behind it.

🧠 A Better Question Than “How Did They Do It?”

There are no fewer than a couple of dozen thinkpieces this week on Indiana’s season. Most of the conversation has focused on how this happened.

But the more interesting question is why this kind of leadership works so rarely.

In an era defined by:

• constant movement

• performative culture

• outcome-driven pressure

• and borrowed philosophies

While most athletic departments are chasing innovation, Indiana doubled and tripled down on fundamentals. It was restraint that contributed to their success. Not change.

Watching this team all year felt like watching a leader who knew exactly who he was and refused to negotiate with the moment.

That clarity starts at the top.

🧭 What We Noticed Watching This Season

This team is worth studying. It’s somewhat of a unicorn. Many have said this type of thing can no longer happen in the modern age of NCAA Athletics, yet it did.

What are the biggest leadership lessons to learn from this team?

1️⃣ Identity Came Before Strategy

The head coach wasn’t trying to be the loudest voice in the room or the most modern one. He wasn’t auditioning for approval.

He led from a settled identity and built a program that reflected it.

Great leadership doesn’t begin with what you run.
It begins with who you are.

2️⃣ Continuity Was Treated Like a Superpower

In a sport obsessed with upgrades, Indiana leaned into alignment.

Staff continuity. Shared language. Trust is built over time.

Retention of people and principles created performance that outmatched all other programs.

Leadership → Culture → Performance.

3️⃣ Fundamentals Were Lived, Not Branded

Every program talks about “process.”

Very few define it clearly. Even fewer return to it relentlessly.

What stood out here was repetition without fatigue. The same priorities, the same standards, the same focus, week after week.

Not because it sounded good.
Because it worked.

4️⃣ Emotional Consistency Was the Culture

Wins didn’t inflate them. Mistakes didn’t fracture them.

The leader’s demeanor never became the distraction.

That emotional steadiness did something powerful:
It removed noise and let players think clearly under pressure.

5️⃣ Be the Best at Playing the Hand You're Dealt

It would be the easiest thing in the world for coaches to blame the lack of resources compared to the bigger, better-funded school down the road.

Cignetti didn’t do that. He looked at the reality of their situation and made a commitment to being the best at building that type of program.

Now, did Indiana end up spending on this team? Yes.

But it was earned by building a program full of 0-3-star players and committing to their development over time, because that was what they could be good at relative to their competitors.

Stop complaining about your hand. Be the best at playing that hand. You might find (like Indiana just did) that it becomes your competitive advantage.

🪞 The Leadership Mirror

It’s easy to admire this from a distance.

Harder to ask:

• Where have I traded clarity for convenience?

• Where do I preach values but reward exceptions?

• Where am I asking for buy-in without modeling consistency?

• Where has outcome pressure pulled me away from who I am?

This season wasn’t proof that Indiana cracked a code.

It was proof that leadership fundamentals still work if you’re willing to live them.

🏁 Closing Reflection:

There is no secret here.

Just a leader who:

• knew who he was

• valued his people

• committed to the process

• and behaved consistently when it mattered

In a landscape full of noise, that kind of clarity feels rare. It’s not complicated. It demands discipline.

And discipline always costs something.

🛠️ Want to Build Elite Culture?

Get BETTER’s Culture Playbook. A system designed to install a thriving, healthy, high-performance culture. Join over 1,000 coaches who use our Culture Playbook from youth club teams to national championship NCAA programs and everything in between.