- BETTER
- Posts
- š¤ Why the Best Coaches Don't Need a Halftime Speech
š¤ Why the Best Coaches Don't Need a Halftime Speech
šŖ Motivation isnāt about what you tell your team. Itās about what your team believes about you.

ā³ Read Time: 4 min
Quick Note: The Game Within
Weāve been asked a lot in recent weeks about our work with athletes, primarily by parents of high school athletes, high school coaches, and even athletes themselves.
Our working title for the entire mental performance pathway is āThe Game Withināāweāve written about it extensively in this newsletter and detailed each part.
We donāt have every piece ready for an athlete to do on their own. But weāve shared the first part (āAddressing Fearā) so much that it's easy to share with anyone.
If you want to see it to use with one of your athletes or an athlete you know, reply to this email. We are happy to share it with anyone. No strings attached.
š Whatās inside:
š The myth: Motivation as messaging
š§ The research: What actually drives motivation
š” 5 ways to lead for lasting motivation ā without saying a word
š The Work Beneath the Work
You can have your Ted Lasso. Weāll take Coach Eric Taylor.
Weāve all seen the movie moment.
The coach storms into the locker room at halftime, delivers the perfect speech, and the team explodes onto the field inspired.
Say it with us. Clear Eyes. Full Hearts. Canāt Lose!
Itās beautiful. Itās dramatic, itās cinematic. But hereās what they donāt tell you in coaching school:
This is mostly a myth.
We canāt quite put our finger on where it started (probably a combination of Vince Lombardi and some famous sports movies), but coaches have come to believe that clips like this one are what leadership is. They think this is motivation.
And thatās certainly one part of motivation. Listen, there is certainly something to firing your team up. But, we get asked to help with āmessagingā so much that weāve started to ask:
āDo coaches think that choosing their messaging is their primary leadership?ā
Quick Aside: Yes, there has been research done on whether or not pregame speeches are beneficial. Weāve read it. Thereās not much, and more needs to be done.
TLDR version is: Pregame speeches can and will impact how your athletes FEEL. Itās unclear if they impact performance. In fact, when measured against performance, pregame speeches have been found to be just as harmful as they are helpful
Hereās what most coaches miss when they get inspired to be like Coach Taylor in the clip above:
Motivation doesnāt come from words. It comes from belief.
If your team doesnāt believe in you, no speech will save you.
If they do, your āmessagingā will be more effective.
Thatās the real secret:
The most powerful motivator isnāt the message ā itās the messenger.
The truth is, the best halftime speeches are lived, not spoken.
Theyāre built over months of consistency, honesty, and care ā long before you ever open your mouth.
When your team believes in your leadership, your words have power.
When they donāt, even the best message falls flat.
We want to help you be the leader who doesnāt have to craft messages to motivate. Who you are motivates, regardless of what you say.
š Research Insight: Motivation Starts With Belief
Research in Self-Determination Theory (Deci & Ryan, 2000) shows that lasting motivation doesnāt come from external hype or rewards. Itās built when three internal needs are met:
Autonomy: People feel ownership of what theyāre doing.
Competence: They believe their effort leads to progress.
Relatedness: They trust the people theyāre working with.
Leaders who consistently meet these needs ā who empower, develop, and genuinely connect with their people ā donāt have to ācreateā motivation. They cultivate it.
We say again: Messenger > Message
š ļø Putting It All Together:
š” 5 Ways to Lead For Lasting Motivation
Be consistent, not charismatic.
Yes, sometimes teams want emotional fireworks, but what they really need is emotional stability.
Consistency builds belief.
Connect before you correct.
People wonāt be motivated by someone they donāt feel connected to.
Relationship always precedes results.
Let ownership drive energy.
Involve your players or staff in defining goals and standards.
Motivation rises when people help build what theyāre working toward.
Model composure under pressure.
Calm is contagious.
Decide (and write down) the leader you want to be in those moments before you get there.
This practice helps in one moment. An entire Voice Guide will help you do this in every moment, not just the high-pressure ones.
Live the message before you deliver it.
Your actions communicated 100 times louder than your pregame talk.
When youāre team believes in you, theyāll believe in your words.
š Conclusion: The Work that Impacts the Rest
Motivation isnāt a moment you create ā itās a byproduct of the leader you are.
Words inspire for a day.
Belief inspires for a season.
The next time youāre tempted to craft the perfect message, focus instead on being the kind of leader who doesnāt have to.
P.S. If youāve already received and read PowerBook 2, youāll recognize the connection here: true motivation begins with identity.
Pre-Order The Full Book: Lead Yourself First!
When you pre-order, youāll get:
ā
Immediate access to the next two PowerBooks as soon as theyāre released
šļø A downloadable implementation guide for PowerBook 1 - You Are The Culture
š„ Access to our monthly leadership webinars inside the BETTER Community
š A physical copy of Lead Yourself First when the full section is complete
š ļø Want to win more? Know Yourself First.
Just last week, nearly 400 leaders signed up for our 5-day leadership course based on your Voice!

It will be sent to your inbox starting the Monday after you take the assessment and run for that week.
The assessment takes 10-15 minutes. Take it below.